Thursday, September 27, 2012

THE CLASH BETWEEN SCIENCE AND THE PUBLIC


 “… journalism will never be a cautious profession as long as its aim is to find and communicate events that are of interest to broad sectors of society.”

A mind-hitting statement from the European Molecular Biology Organization(EMBO) in their 7th volume of journal article regarding the bad science in the headlines on news articles. This article analyzes the pro’s and con’s of journalistic writing in delivering scientific information to the public.

It was indeed a great help to the science community if their researches are appreciated by the public. The downside of journalistic writing is that some information is being overlooked if expertise in this specific field of science is absent. The information may be distorted instead of gaining support from the public. In the Philippines, information roaming regarding the efficiency of Tawa-tawa as cure to Dengue disease. Because of this misconception, the public are victimized because of the falsity of the information written on these news articles.
Another example would be the use of Gluthathione as a reagent in skin whitening products. Several studies have proven that addition of gluthathione to whitening beauty products would hasten the whitening process of skin but, on the other hand, its side-effects had also reached the ears of the consumers, as a result: avoid using it, in the end, the manufacturer or the scientist behind the science of glutha is affected. His credibility and capability as a scientist will be ignored. Another example is the
That’s the reason why some scientist tends to keep their researches privately and do not share their researches to the public – to avoid public criticism and to gain their self-worth as a renowned professional.

The role of a journalist
Through the use of flowery and metaphoric words, a journalist is more capable of persuading the public on such science facts. As a journalist, he should know what role he is playing when writing for science community. He should have an expertise in that field of science to avoid misinterpreting scientific information; a good background in science will do; not biased and always state the positive and negative side and avoid being clingy to one side; be fair and factual. These should prevail when writing articles.

The role of a scientist
Basically, a scientist researches in a laboratory, with no one but his microscope and specimen. Thorough researches are being made to find developments on an existing science knowledge.
The journalist vs. the scientist
If a journalist and a scientist are going to argue on a specific science fact, let’s say, an argument between BT corn or biotechnically engineered corn. A journalist may wrote a biased article disagreeing with the marketing of BT corn. While on the other hand, a scientist would stand on what he believes is right, according to the result of the study. The clash between a journalist and a scientist starts when a journalist wrote an article regarding the side effects, whether positive or negative, of the product of science. With this, the journalist has more edge to the public compared with a scientist because through writing, he has a more advantage in persuading the public.

According to EMBO, “irresponsible reporting is not usually due to ignorance or lack of appropriate experience but rather it happens when the original story takes on a broader significance,” means that a journalist may really tend to broader or add up some irrelevant information to a science facts and end up to distortion of facts which have a more impact on the science community. Some factors such as demand for a page space in a newspaper or airtime value in broadcasting, is an investment to media people and because of this, both side are being affected, either the public or the scientist. But the bottomline is, everyone of us are responsible in everything that we speak or write, may it be negative or positive and it’s our choice if we choose freedom over integrity.

No comments:

Post a Comment